Now booking through May 2023! View our Calendar to book tickets NOW!
“Summertime and the living is easy” — except when it’s 90 degrees out and all you want is a cold, sweet treat to cool you down. Colorado Springs is full of fun ice cream shops. Soft serve, slow churned, dairy free, and rolled — there’s something for every ice cream lover!
We offer food tours in Colorado Springs and know good food! So, the next time you’re about to head out to grab a cold treat from the grocery store, check out one of these unique, local ice cream spots instead!
Here’s a list of nine exceptional ice cream shops in Colorado Springs, in no particular order:
What started as a dream between two college friends became one of Colorado Springs’ favorite local spots. In 1986, two Colorado College graduates, Josh and John, opened up shop in downtown Colorado Springs. Since the beginning, their ice cream has been slowly churned in turn-of-the-century rock salt and ice freezers, making their cream exceptionally creamy and full of flavor. They’ve since moved to a bigger location and opened three new locations in Colorado Springs and Fort Collins. Josh and John’s Ice Cream has some incredible unique flavors alongside some creamy classics.
Try our favorite ice cream on select routes of The Original Colorado Springs Food Tour!
What to order: You really can’t go wrong, but we love the Purple Mountain Majesty (which has luscious dark chocolate raspberry truffles mixed in) in one of their homemade cinnamon waffle cones!
BJ’s Velvet Freez is as classic as they come! They’ve been serving soft serve ice cream from a small walk-up diner since 1954. Generations have lined up to enjoy their specialities including their sundaes, hot fudge cakes, root beer floats, and dipped soft serve cones. But BJ’s doesn’t just stop with sweets. They have an array of savory items on their menu including cheeseburgers, sandwiches, and hot dogs. So, step right up and keep the tradition alive!
What to order: The Peanut Delight is a must-try, which is a layered sundae filled with ice cream, fudge, and topped with peanuts and whipped cream.
Frozen Gold is one of the newer kids on the block in downtown Colorado Springs, joining other fun spots on S. Tejon Street like Dos Santos, Atomic Cowboy, and Cork and Cask. They’re serving up soft serve ice cream like you’ve never had it before — using toppings like salted potato sticks, Cheetos, and Pop Rocks. Their ice cream isn’t the only thing that’s funky. The environment feels like the Jetsons had a hip and trendy baby with downtown Los Angeles. The next time you venture down Tejon Street, to grab some tacos, whiskey, or pizza, and end your evening with a tasty soft serve treat to remember.
What to order: While they have so many fun and unique flavors, we’re loving their Samoa Samoa, inspired by everyone’s favorite Girl Scout Cookie. This flavor is completely vegan, but it’s as creamy and sweet as anything you’ve ever had.
If summer was a place, it would be Tasty Freeze. Step back into the 1950s with Colorado Springs’ best kept secret. Imagine red umbrellas, a colorful neon sign lighting up the block, and the nostalgia of eating an ice cream cone before the heat melts it in your hand. Situated on the east edge of The Old North End, one of Colorado Springs’ most historic neighborhoods, Tasty Freeze feels like a well-kept secret for the downtown community. There’s no indoor seating, so summer is the primetime to make your trip for some classic soft serve, sundaes, or shakes. And if you need some more sustenance, they’ve got you covered with burgers, hotdogs, fries, and beyond.
What to order: We love a good sprinkle-dipped soft serve, but if you’re up for something a little different, try their chocolate shake mixed with coffee and Oreo crumbles.
The Ice Cream Lab might be the most unique shop in town – and they’re getting a new downtown location! Specializing in liquid nitrogen and rolled ice cream, they definitely experiment when it comes to the classic treat we all know and love. This science themed ice cream shop serves treats completely made to order by flash freezing the cream and scooping it fresh in front of the customer. Opening up soon in downtown after calling Old Colorado City their original home, this is the perfect pit stop as you relax in Acacia Park.
What to order: Where else can you order rolled ice cream in a waffle cone taco?! Whatever you get at the Ice Cream Lab, make sure you’re ready to try something you’ve never had before! While the Ice Cream Lab is in between brick-and-mortar locations, they are still taking catering orders.
Located in a small yellow ice cream parlor right in the heart of Old Colorado City, the Colorado City Creamery has been making ice cream the old fashioned way for decades. They have 32 flavors ranging from bubble gum to French Silk to Café de Leche. A stop at the creamery is a must-do after an afternoon of shopping and sightseeing along historic Colorado Avenue.
What to order: While all of their flavors make our mouths water, our favorite by far is their peppermint ice cream!
The mission behind starting Legit Gelato Colorado is simple: bring authentic — or, dare I say, “legit” — Italian gelato to downtown Colorado Springs. And it was so. The handmade, small batch gelato and “sorbettos” are made from organic ingredients, are GMO-free and gluten-free, and don’t use added color. And for all you vegans or dairy sensitive folks out there, there’s always a vegan option available. All-in-all, they’re the real deal. While Legit Gelato doesn’t yet have a storefront location, Stellina Pizza Cafe, JAX Fish House and Oyster Bar, and Salad or Bust are said to serve up their gelato goodness.
What to order: There’s nothing better on a hot day than their lemon gelato, which is made from fresh lemons.
Javalato Gelato & Cafe serves up gourmet gelatos and sorbets on the north side of Colorado Springs. Not only do they offer delicious gelato, but their menu also includes breakfast, brunch, lunch, and specialty coffee drinks. Their ingredients are completely pure — the vibrant colors of their gelatos come solely from plant and vegetable extracts, and all of their flavors come from real fruits and nuts. This is truly a “guilt-free dessert.”
What to order: We love interesting flavors, so we have our eye on the peach basil sorbet!
4785 Barnes Rd., Colorado Springs, CO 80917
Rizuto’s Ice Cream is a popular neighborhood shop known for serving our favorite summertime sweet treat at an affordable price. This family-owned business prides themselves on serving “the largest handmade scoops,” usually to bright-eyed children. Their goal is to put a smile on everyone’s face, and they accomplish that with their amazing array of ice cream flavors, monster shakes, and cotton candy.
What to order: With so many sweets and treats to choose from, we are partial to the Italian Gelato, which they make using their own secret recipe.
Don’t know what a paleta is? If not, you’ve definitely been missing out! Paleta is Spanish for “ice pop,” and they come in a variety of flavors. The Paleta Bar, which is inside CO.A.T.I. food hall, makes these upscale popsicles everyday from either a fruit or sweet cream base. Once you’ve selected your flavor – which could be flavors like mango, almond, or pistachio – you can then customize your treat to suit your tastebuds. Add candy or nut toppings, fresh fruit pieces, or have your paleta dipped in chocolate or chili powder.
What to order: Feeling adventurous? Try a strawberry paleta dipped in white chocolate and then sprinkled with chili powder!
Whether you’re the more traditional type or want something a little more global and experimental, grab your ice cream, sit back, and enjoy the sunshine!
Cheers! Your Rocky Mountain Food Tours Team
(So, what’s a food tour, anyway…?)
attractionseditor's pickevents & holidaysgift ideashistorylocal diningtours we've takentravel
which Let this be your personal guide for things to do in Colorado Springs this Spring Break with your family! Springtime in the Rockies can be wonderful! If you’re planning a visit to Colorado Springs this Spring Break or perhaps are entertaining out-of-town guests, consider some of these local attractions. Some are more popular, and … Read more 10 Family-Friendly Things to do in Colorado Springs for Spring Break
Read More
Valentine’s Events in Colorado Springs Want to get creative this Valentine’s Day? There are plenty of unique events to celebrate with your special someone in Colorado Springs! Valentine’s Day falls on a Tuesday this year, which means that you can easily celebrate the weekend before or after! If you’re planning on celebrating Valentine’s Day in … Read more 10 Unique Ways to Celebrate Valentine’s Day in Colorado Springs
Read More
From thrilling adventures to culinary explorations, Colorado Springs is the perfect place for crossing items off your bucket list! Here’s our list of top things to do in Colorado Springs in 2023. Whether you’re visiting Colorado Springs for the first time or call this beautiful city home, there are plenty of bucket list activities that … Read more 8 Things to Add to Your 2023 Colorado Springs Bucket List
Read More
Hey, Santa! A gift card to a food tour in Colorado Springs makes the perfect gift this holiday season. Shop local and surprise your special someone with a unique gift idea! Holiday shopping is in full-force, and if you’re like us, you’re busy crossing items off your gift list. We’re here to help you be … Read more 8 Reasons Why a Food Tour Gift Card is the Perfect Gift
Read MoreWe write a new blog article every two weeks! Stay on top of foodies news in Colorado Springs, plus be the first to hear about new food tours and receive exclusive discounts.
